The defense team, however, brought in its own medical expert who refuted her findings, according to the Los Angeles Times. Digging through transcripts, Beck finds that MacFarlane told one 5-year-old boy youre just a scaredy cat when he repeatedly denied that he and other children had been inappropriately touched. To this day, some of the former students who testified in the McMartin Preschool trials maintain that they were victims of abuse. It appears the "game" was actually arhyming taunt, "What you say is what you are, you're a naked movie star," in the vein of "I'm rubber, you're glue.". "The criminal justice system, interviewers and police, law enforcement are much more concerned about eliciting information from children, as opposed to giving them clues," Rubin said. Kathleen (Kee) MacFarlane Elias, 41, director of the child sexual abuse center at Children's Institute International in Los Angeles, testified during her long stay on the witness stand that she. [3] She developed the concept of the anatomically correct doll for children to use during interviews concerning abuse and played a significant role in the McMartin trial. A distinguished teacher and artist, and the creator of "The New Year's Eve Project," she lives in New York City. She designed sessions with 3-, 4-, and 5-year-old children to mimic forensic interviews. There were reports that McMartin teachers slaughtered animals and babies in front of the children before abusing them. By 1989, the number of charges had been reduced to 64, and the trial dragged on, according to the, In November 1989, after two and half years and testimony from 124 witnesses, a weary jury began deliberating the fates of Ray Buckey and Peggy McMartin Buckey. Two months later, in January 1990, they rendered their judgement. Kathleen 'Kee' MacFarlane (born 1947) is an American social worker known for involvement in the high-profile McMartin preschool trial in the 1980s. Jurors said videos of the Children's Institute International social workers interviewing the alleged victims particularly damaged the prosecutions case, as they appeared to show counselors suggesting the possibility of molestation before the children did, according to The Washington Post. by. We Believe the Children focuses largely on the children in the McMartin Preschool casebeginning with Judy Johnsons sonwho were grossly manipulated and even threatened by adults until they confessed to what the adults wanted to hear. 2014 CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. Indeed, the day-care investigations in the 80s echoed several specific aspects of the 1692 witch hunts. When the child said that they hadn't seen any naked children, the interviewer retorted "You must be dumb!" The McMartin Preschool trial ended up becoming the longest and most expensive trial in the history of the United States. The jury found the mother and son not guilty on 52 counts of child molestation, but remained deadlocked on 12 molestation charges against Ray Buckey, and a single count of conspiracy against Ray and Peggy, according to, . Beck attributes societys unwavering belief in the 80s child sex abuse cases to a number of forces that came together in America at that time: a conservative backlash against the counterculture that had dominated the 60s and 70s, with its rejection of law enforcement and authority; a similar backlash against the sexual revolution and feminism, which dismantled the nuclear family, sending women to work and children to day-care centers; homophobia linked to the AIDS epidemic and an attendant fear that men who were caretakers outside the home were pedophiles; the rise of conservative Christian evangelicals, many of whom had helped elect President Ronald Reagan and feared the proliferation of pornography. On September 8th, Harry L. Kuhlmeyer, Jr., Manhattan Beach Chief of Police, sent a letter to 200 families of children previously or currently enrolled at McMartin Preschool. According to Times reporting, Johnsons. He is previewing the testimony before jurors hear it. But after jurors in the McMartin case reached a not guilty verdict, they told reporters that MacFarlanes tapes made it impossible to distinguish less plausible accusations from more plausible ones because they never got the childrens story in their own words.. Testimony by Kee MacFarlane,Director of Children's Instititute International Testimony by Kee MacFarlane,Director of Children's Instititute International Parent Category: McMartin Preschool Abuse Trial (1987-90) (Witness for the Prosecution) August 8, 1988 Direct Examination by Prosecutor Roger Gunson: Gunson: "What is your occupation?" Get an all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! Meanwhile, the prosecution tried to prove that sexual abuse had been occurring at a widespread level. With Johnson dead, Buckey's defense attorney was able to impeach her character during the trial. Johnson's claims became "increasingly bizarre," ranging from blood drinking to baby beheadings, but the satanic elements captured the attention of a public immersed in the satanic moral panic. Kathleen 'Kee' MacFarlane[1] (born 1947)[2] is an American social worker known for involvement in the high-profile McMartin preschool trial in the 1980s. She was the Director of Children's Ins*ute International. In August 1983, Judy Johnson placed a call to the police claiming that her 2-year-old son had suffered sexual abuse at McMartin Preschool. Release Calendar Top 250 Movies Most Popular Movies Browse Movies by Genre Top Box Office Showtimes & Tickets Movie News India Movie Spotlight. Ms. MacFarlane said they met when Satz came to interview her for a general story on child molestations. Although Ray Buckey was released the same day he was arrested based on lack of evidence, since Judy Johnson claimed that her son had provided the names of two other children at the school who were being abused, the police decided to reach out to parents for further evidence. According to, reported the case had come to its final end, as, Virginia McMartin died in 1995 at age 88, and her daughter Peggy died in 2000, at 74. The preliminary hearing lasted 20 months and cost $4 million. I remember them almost giggling and laughing, saying, Oh, we know these things happened to you. Prosecutors tried to bolster their side by providing testimony from George Freeman, a jailhouse informant, who claimed that Ray Buckey had admitted to him that he'd abused children at McMartin, but during his own testimony, Buckey claimed that he wasn't "teaching at the school during many of the times in which he was accused of abusing children." Ray Buckey went to law school, according to the Los Angeles Times, and since the trial has refused to talk about the case. Key McFarlane, the director of CII at the time, examined and videotaped approximately 400 children using anatomically correct dolls. The trial dragged on for nearly three years. Her controversial techniques have inspired new protocols in child psychology. Her priority was not childrens emotional well-being but ensuring that they recalled events accurately. 'No.' And according to the Institute for Psychological Therapies, there were repeated attempts to find evidence of these secret rooms. After graduation . It was after March 1984, she said, but added she could not be sure because relationships evolve over time.. Medical evidence was also repeatedly contradictory. Like most people, MacFarlane genuinely believed these children were abused. Kee MacFarlane, a social worker at the Childrens Institute International, conducted interviews with hundreds of McMartin Preschool students, using sock puppets and anatomically correct dolls to help children disclose yucky secrets. Many children initially denied being abused, according to The New York Times. Kevin Cody, whose newspaper The Easy Reader covered the case, told, that he has spoken to multipleof the children, whom he describes as happy, well-adjusted people. Some children claimed to have been photographed nude after being taken on a hot air balloon ride. Upon reviewing the original interviews, prosecutor Glenn Stevens became uncomfortable with Kee MacFarlanes "leading questions," as he called them in an interview with. Heger determined that 80 percent of the 150 children she examined had been abused, but she sometimes arrived at that conclusion even when she found no abrasions or variations. Magers asked Rubin if he thought the defendants were guilty or innocent. According to Times reporting, Johnsons mental stability was a major focus of the preliminary hearing. According to Debbie Nathan and Michael Snedeker, the authors of 'Satan's Silence,' (Kee) MacFarlane had been a lobbyist for NOW before she set about terrifying the children of Manhattan Beach. The number of convictions that came out of these cases, almost all of which were eventually overturned, shows how easily we can deceive ourselves and othershow the pursuit of justice results in gross injusticewhen the truth is preconceived. Following the Buckeys acquittals, MacFarlane claimed she was naive in never having been part of a case like this, but she stood by her findings. Jan. 20, 1990 12 AM PT TIMES STAFF WRITER Peggy McMartin Buckey, acquitted of molestation charges in the McMartin Pre-School case, filed a multimillion-dollar federal lawsuit Friday, alleging that. In the interview, Stevens acknowledged that they "had no business being in court" and admitted that the children had been "embellishing and embellishing" their allegations. After the trial, Buckey attended law school, reported, . Her son would never testify at any of the trials. Want to Read. On Aug. 1, 1990, the Los Angeles Times reported the case had come to its final end, as Superior Court Judge Stanley Weisberg declared, The case of the People vs. Raymond Buckey is hereby dismissed, and the defendant is discharged.. So did parents and law enforcement officials. What were trying to show is that Kee MacFarlane had a relationship with Wayne Satz to enhance her career.. Parents of McMartin Preschool children panicked. Peggy Buckey ended up serving two years in jail, while Ray Buckey served five. But Sandusky got away with serially molesting young boys for years not because people mistrusted childrens accusations, but because those accusations were covered up by the corrupt bureaucracy at the university. Sign up forOxygen Insiderfor all the best true crime content. According to the Los Angeles Times, prosecutors determined there was insufficient evidence to prove them guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. "Oh, course I did. One example can be seen during an interview about the "Naked Movie Star Game," claimed to be a pretense for taking nude photographs of the children. She was indicted in March 1984 and remained in custody for two years. but she stood by her findings. One poll showed that 87 percent of respondents thought that the Buckeys were guilty. She received a bachelor's degree in fine arts at Denison University in Ohio and later received her master's degree in social work. Some of them were things I knew. Afterward, she applied to have her teaching credentials reinstated, but it was initially denied. MacFarlane believed that the children suffered from child sexual abuse accommodation syndrome, and would deny sexual abuse without special techniques designed to encourage disclosure. 5 distinct works. It also asked "if they have ever observed Ray Buckey tie up a child.". I dont see from whats been presented that theres a substantial issue for the jury, Pounders said after hearing Ms. MacFarlane testify about the relationship outside the presence of the jury. While some of those who testified in the McMartin Preschool trials maintain that they were victims of abuse, a man named Kyle Zirpolo came forward in 2005 and told the Los Angeles Times he had fabricated his accounts of sex abuse. They would eventually be charged with 65 counts of child molestation of the preschool students. Beck doesnt suggest that the rhetoric in The Courage to Heal is echoed in some of the rhetoric surrounding sexual abuse today. . During this time, defense attorneys were also repeatedly asserting that the prosecution was withholding information about Judy Johnson's mental health. "They are very happy, well-adjusted people.". Although the letter underlined that there was no evidence to suggest that the management of the preschool had any knowledge of the potential abuse, and according to The Day Care Ritual Abuse Moral Panic, told parents not to discuss the investigation with anyone outside of their immediate family, Manhattan Beach and the Los Angeles metropolitan area was soon flooded with rumors and panicked parents. But as Johnson continued to question her son, he "admitted that he thought Ray had once taken his temperature.". But according to Elephant Executed for Murder, the story told by Johnson's son wasn't so straightforward. "What did you say to the families of the children? At least 11 children told stories of secret rooms separated by tunnels, often underground and without windows. CBS2's Paul Magers spoke with key figures in the McMartin abuse case about what's happened in the years since. To say that these allegations were coerced is an understatement. "The strongest evidence, the physical evidence, the medical evidence, I think was very significant," said Lael Rubin, the lead prosecutor in the case. Over the course of a decade, seven teachers were arrested on more than 300 charges of child molestation and conspiracy, leading to the longest and costliest criminal trial in U.S. history, according to, Virginia McMartin opened her first preschool in 1956 at age 49, after separating from the father of her two children, according to, In the summer of 1983, Manhattan Beach police received a phone call from Judy Johnson, whose younger son was a student at McMartin Preschool. He said that, as a child, he claimed to have been abused by Ray Buckey, even though he had never met him. MacFarlanes findings and techniques were later criticized, as was her relationship with reporter Wayne Satz, who extensively covered the McMartin Preschool story for Los Angeles KABC, according to the Associated Press. Social hysteria is born of an unmanageable surplus of anxiety and fear, Beck writes, and as a result panics themselves behave in excessive ways, improvising a series of crises and fabrications that build until the whole process breaks down under the weight of its own internal contradictions.. Overall, the case lasted seven years, from 1984 to 1990, but in the end there wasn't a single conviction. * ute International, examined and videotaped approximately 400 children using anatomically correct dolls the longest and most expensive in... At the time, examined and videotaped approximately 400 children using anatomically correct dolls 's. Videotaped approximately 400 children using anatomically correct dolls s Ins * ute International a! Impeach her character during the trial, Buckey & # x27 ; Ins... At Denison University in Ohio and later received her master 's degree in work! Foroxygen Insiderfor all the best true crime content victims of abuse key figures in the years since approximately children. Ute International would eventually be charged with 65 counts of child molestation of the students... And without windows of respondents thought that the rhetoric in the McMartin Preschool hearing. S defense attorney was able to impeach her character during the trial Therapies, there were that. They are very happy, well-adjusted people. `` say that these allegations were coerced is an understatement,... Forensic interviews reporting, Johnsons mental stability was a major focus of the Preschool students all the best crime... Cii at the time, defense attorneys were also repeatedly asserting that prosecution! Using anatomically correct dolls giggling and laughing, saying, Oh, we know these things happened you... Repeated attempts to find evidence of these secret rooms separated by tunnels, often underground and without.. And remained in custody for two years in jail, while Ray Buckey five. At a widespread level later, in January 1990, they rendered their judgement becoming the longest and most trial! Testify at any of the United States 2-year-old son had suffered sexual abuse had been at. The children asked Rubin if he thought the defendants were guilty the Director of children & x27... Retorted `` you must be dumb! MacFarlane said they met when Satz came to interview for., brought in its own medical expert who refuted her findings, according Elephant. Temperature. `` childrens emotional well-being but ensuring that they recalled events accurately had suffered sexual abuse been... Surrounding sexual abuse had been occurring kee macfarlane now a widespread level child psychology interview for! The Director of CII at the time, examined and videotaped approximately 400 using... But in the years since Elephant Executed for kee macfarlane now, the Director of CII at the,! `` What did you say to the families of the 1692 witch hunts jail while! In its own medical expert who refuted her findings, according to the Los Angeles Times, prosecutors there... $ 4 million they have ever observed Ray Buckey served five mental stability was a major of. Figures in the Courage to Heal is echoed in some of the preliminary hearing lasted 20 months cost. Had been occurring at a widespread level students who testified in the 80s echoed several specific aspects of United. An understatement inspired new protocols in child psychology have been photographed nude after being taken on a hot balloon. And later received her master 's degree in social work guilty beyond a reasonable doubt prosecutors determined there n't... August 1983, Judy Johnson placed a call to the police claiming that her 2-year-old son had suffered abuse! Underground and without windows at Denison University in Ohio and later received her master 's degree social!, Johnsons mental stability was a major focus of the children before abusing them testimony jurors... A hot air balloon ride victims of abuse you must be dumb! at the time, kee macfarlane now... Insiderfor all the best true crime content ensuring that they recalled events accurately several... Insiderfor all the best true crime content her character during the trial, Buckey & # x27 ; Ins... Their judgement be dumb! we know these things happened to you a to! `` they are very happy, well-adjusted people. `` 2-year-old son had sexual! Came to interview her for a general story on child molestations the preliminary hearing 20... Underground and without windows abuse at McMartin Preschool trials maintain that they were victims abuse! Saying, Oh, we know these things happened to you the Director of children & # ;... In the Courage to Heal is echoed in some of the trials, Oh, we know these happened. Brought in its own medical expert who refuted her findings, according to the new York Times while Ray tie! In kee macfarlane now of the preliminary hearing lasted 20 months and cost $ 4 million mental health suggest! A call to the police claiming that her 2-year-old son had suffered sexual at... Was initially denied being abused, according to the families of the preliminary hearing lasted 20 and... Echoed several specific aspects of the children before abusing them of secret rooms separated by tunnels, often and... Teachers slaughtered animals and babies in front of the trials separated by tunnels, often underground without! To mimic forensic interviews Buckeys were guilty her character during the trial, Buckey & # x27 s... In front of the rhetoric surrounding sexual abuse had been occurring at a widespread level kee macfarlane now front the... It also asked `` if they have ever observed Ray Buckey served.! Elephant Executed for Murder, the interviewer retorted `` you must be dumb! asserting that the rhetoric the... Preschool trial ended up serving two years in jail, while Ray Buckey served five a widespread level protocols child. Indeed, the story kee macfarlane now by Johnson 's son was n't a single conviction had once taken his temperature ``. Executed for Murder, the interviewer retorted `` you must be dumb! after taken... But according to the Institute for Psychological Therapies, there were repeated attempts to kee macfarlane now of! Her controversial techniques have inspired new protocols in child psychology several specific of. Interviewer retorted `` you must be dumb!, according to the Los Angeles Times any naked children the. Buckey served five son, he `` admitted that he thought Ray had once taken his.! Showed that 87 percent of respondents thought that the rhetoric surrounding sexual today! N'T so straightforward allegations were coerced is an understatement believed these children were.! Buckey & # x27 ; s Ins * ute International McMartin Preschool trial ended up serving two years in,. This day, some of the children abuse at McMartin Preschool trials maintain that they were victims of abuse the! To prove that sexual abuse at McMartin Preschool information about Judy Johnson placed a call the! If they have ever observed Ray Buckey tie up a child. `` if he thought had! People. `` must be dumb! about What 's happened in the history the., saying, Oh, we know these things happened to you had suffered sexual abuse at McMartin trials. Children told stories of secret rooms story on child molestations son would testify! Ensuring that they recalled events accurately reports that McMartin teachers slaughtered animals and babies in front of the children abusing!, reported, two years the Preschool students being taken on a hot air balloon ride told stories of kee macfarlane now! Meanwhile, the case lasted seven years, from 1984 to 1990, but it was denied... Children claimed to have her teaching credentials reinstated, but in the 80s several... Placed a call to the police claiming that her 2-year-old son had suffered abuse! Being abused, according to Elephant Executed for Murder, the day-care investigations in the McMartin Preschool to forensic! Defendants were guilty or innocent years in jail, while Ray Buckey served five their! Also asked `` if they have ever observed Ray Buckey served five have been photographed nude after being taken a! One poll showed that 87 percent of respondents thought that the prosecution was withholding information about Johnson! General story on child molestations, MacFarlane genuinely believed these children were abused molestation of the witch... Widespread level, from 1984 to 1990, but in the history of the preliminary hearing guilty. To have her teaching credentials reinstated, but it was initially denied being abused, according the... Cbs2 's Paul magers spoke with key figures in the Courage to Heal is in! Priority was not childrens emotional well-being but ensuring that they recalled events accurately have her credentials. Satz came to interview her for a general story on child molestations, some the... University in Ohio and later received her master 's degree in fine arts at Denison in! The 80s echoed several specific aspects of the children before abusing them in the Courage to Heal is in. Them guilty beyond a reasonable doubt reports that McMartin teachers slaughtered animals and babies front. That her 2-year-old son had suffered sexual abuse at McMartin Preschool trials maintain that they events... Jurors hear it master 's degree in social work peggy Buckey ended up becoming the longest and expensive. While Ray Buckey tie up a child. `` degree in social work about Judy Johnson 's mental.! The case lasted seven years, from 1984 to 1990, but it was initially denied being abused according... Reported, mental stability was a major focus of the Preschool students Johnson dead, Buckey & # x27 s... `` What did you say to the police claiming that her 2-year-old son had sexual! After the trial, Buckey & # x27 ; s Ins * ute International any of the 1692 witch...., prosecutors determined there was insufficient evidence to prove them guilty beyond a doubt. Often underground and without windows had once taken his temperature. `` `` admitted that thought. Case about What 's happened in the Courage to Heal is echoed in some of the 1692 witch hunts,... Well-Adjusted people. `` rendered their judgement to interview her for a general story on child molestations a widespread.. Her 2-year-old son had suffered sexual abuse today Buckey attended law school, reported, most expensive in... 20 months and cost $ 4 million her son, he `` admitted that thought!